* Reviews, Recommendations and More! * Established 2011 * New posts first Saturday of each month (or when life allows) *
Showing posts with label feminism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label feminism. Show all posts
26 June 2023
'Broken Light' by Joanne Harris
As long term readers of this blog know, I'm a sucker for an interesting premise. So when I heard 'Broken Light' by Joanne Harris described as what would've happened if Stephen King's Carrie had gained her supernatural powers with the menopause instead of at puberty, I instantly wanted to find out more.
Labels:
book,
chocolat,
feminism,
horror,
men,
review,
sexism,
superheroes,
supernatural,
women
19 June 2023
'Lessons in Chemistry' by Bonnie Garmus
Sometimes, I hear about a book and think 'Ooh, that sounds interesting!', but become doubtful as I hear more and more about how wonderful it is. On the one hand, I know marketers can't perform (many) miracles, but I'm also well aware that it's easy to get swept up by a wave of excitement. This is why I hesitated before reading 'Lessons in Chemistry' by Bonnie Garmus.
07 December 2019
Gilead Reclaimed
'The Testaments' by Margaret Atwood (Chatto & Windus, 2019)
So, where do you start with probably the biggest book of the year, in terms of anticipation, hype and sales? Was there anything more to 'The Testaments' by Margaret Atwood than outstanding branding and an expertly co-ordinated, multi-platform promotional campaign? Well, here are my thoughts, for what they're worth.
So, where do you start with probably the biggest book of the year, in terms of anticipation, hype and sales? Was there anything more to 'The Testaments' by Margaret Atwood than outstanding branding and an expertly co-ordinated, multi-platform promotional campaign? Well, here are my thoughts, for what they're worth.
31 August 2019
Gilead Revisited
'The Handmaid's Tale' by Margaret Atwood
With the release of companion piece 'The Testaments' just ten days away, I've done something I don't normally do - I've re-read a book! So, unsure of whether it was as good as I remembered and with some trepidation, I returned to Gilead and 'The Handmaid's Tale' by Margaret Atwood.22 June 2019
Great Expectations
'Expectation' by Anna Hope (Transworld, 2019)
A few years ago, I read Anna Hope's 'Wake', a thoughtful novel set in the aftermath of the First World War and structured around the return of the Unknown Warrior. This was followed by 'The Ballroom', also set in the early 20th century. In the forthcoming 'Expectation', Hope arrives in the 21st century with a story of three modern women and the challenges faced when dreams don't become reality.
London, 2004: Hannah, Cate and Lissa are best friends, housemates with their whole lives ahead of them and high hopes for successful careers, fulfilling relationships and ongoing friendship. But ten years on, they are not where they expected to be. Despite their best efforts, things have not gone to plan - in work, in marriage or in motherhood. As the gap between their twenty-something aspirations and the thirty-something reality dawns, they struggle to reconcile the two. Faced with an overwhelming desire to salvage something of their youthful hopes and dreams, each acts desperately in a last ditch attempt to find the satisfaction they crave. As obsession, lust and regret take hold, can their friendship survive its greatest test?
A few years ago, I read Anna Hope's 'Wake', a thoughtful novel set in the aftermath of the First World War and structured around the return of the Unknown Warrior. This was followed by 'The Ballroom', also set in the early 20th century. In the forthcoming 'Expectation', Hope arrives in the 21st century with a story of three modern women and the challenges faced when dreams don't become reality.
London, 2004: Hannah, Cate and Lissa are best friends, housemates with their whole lives ahead of them and high hopes for successful careers, fulfilling relationships and ongoing friendship. But ten years on, they are not where they expected to be. Despite their best efforts, things have not gone to plan - in work, in marriage or in motherhood. As the gap between their twenty-something aspirations and the thirty-something reality dawns, they struggle to reconcile the two. Faced with an overwhelming desire to salvage something of their youthful hopes and dreams, each acts desperately in a last ditch attempt to find the satisfaction they crave. As obsession, lust and regret take hold, can their friendship survive its greatest test?
28 April 2019
They Were Only Prostitutes, Weren't They?
'The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper' by Hallie Rubenhold (Doubleday, 2019)
Ask anyone about the 'Jack the Ripper' murder victims, and most people will tell you that they were prostitutes. It's everywhere, from the BBC to Wikipedia. Even Hallie Rubenhold, an author noted for books on the history of women and sex, expected to use the infamous crimes as a gateway into the story of Victorian prostitution. There was just one problem. Her research showed little evidence that three of the five victims were sex workers. Thus the world lost an account of the historical sex trade, but gained an unexpected book about women, history and prejudice - 'The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper'.
Ask anyone about the 'Jack the Ripper' murder victims, and most people will tell you that they were prostitutes. It's everywhere, from the BBC to Wikipedia. Even Hallie Rubenhold, an author noted for books on the history of women and sex, expected to use the infamous crimes as a gateway into the story of Victorian prostitution. There was just one problem. Her research showed little evidence that three of the five victims were sex workers. Thus the world lost an account of the historical sex trade, but gained an unexpected book about women, history and prejudice - 'The Five: The Untold Lives of the Women Killed by Jack the Ripper'.
01 December 2018
Sex and the Spelling
'How to be Famous' by Caitlin Moran
As you may have noticed, I've been stuck in a bit of a reading rut lately. I've started countless books but just couldn't find the energy to finish any of them. Fortunately, feminist, writer and journalist Caitlin Moran has energy to spare and I picked some up via her latest book, 'How to be Famous'.
![]() |
| 'How to be Famous' by Caitlin Moran (Ebury Press, 2018) |
27 May 2018
Telling It Like It Is
One of my favourite podcasts is the Richard Herring's Leicester Square Theatre Podcast (also known as RHLSTP (RHLSTP!)). It ranges from being gloriously vulgar to delightfully insightful and features interviews with a variety of fascinating guests. One of the most interesting was with Jess Phillips MP (number 170), whose book, 'Everywoman: One Woman's Truth About Speaking the Truth' I have just finished.
In 'Everywoman..', Ms Phillips sets the record straight by telling her side of what it's like to be a vocal woman and feminist working in the public eye. In chapters such as 'The Truth About Speaking Up', 'The Truth About Starting a New Career', 'The Truth About Equality', 'The Truth About Winning Elections' and 'The Truth About Trolling', she describes her experiences in life and work and the conclusions they have led her to. Passionate, down-to-earth and driven, Ms Phillips lifts the lid on politics and privilege from her point of view.
In 'Everywoman..', Ms Phillips sets the record straight by telling her side of what it's like to be a vocal woman and feminist working in the public eye. In chapters such as 'The Truth About Speaking Up', 'The Truth About Starting a New Career', 'The Truth About Equality', 'The Truth About Winning Elections' and 'The Truth About Trolling', she describes her experiences in life and work and the conclusions they have led her to. Passionate, down-to-earth and driven, Ms Phillips lifts the lid on politics and privilege from her point of view.
Labels:
book,
equality,
feminism,
non-fiction,
parliament,
politics,
review,
RHLSTP
02 December 2017
Let's all be Champion
After the intensity of 'Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine', I felt I needed a bit of light relief. I'd enjoyed some extracts of Sarah Millican's new book 'How to Be Champion' on the radio, so I decided to give it a go.
Comedian Sarah Millican's 'How to Be Champion' is part memoir, part self-help and part amusing musings on life. Covering subjects as diverse as school, proper jobs, bullying, relationships, getting into stand up and the weirdness of fame, she shares stories, tips and even a recipe, all the while reminding us that life can be both sad and funny and sometimes both. Above all, this book is about how to deal with it in a way that makes you feel 'champion', even when things don't go how you anticipate and society's expectations just want to get in your way.
OK, I'll start with the negative. Like many celebrity books, the structure for this one goes a bit wobbly a bit towards the end. It's almost like there was a set word count and once the timeline from school to the present had been more or less exhausted, there was a sort of 'what do I say now?' moment. Fortunately, it doesn't last too long and Millican regains momentum to get us to the end of the book.
On the whole, this was exactly what I expected and wanted it to be. Millican's joie de vivre shines from every page, meaning that this was a book I was happy to return to and could trust to raise a smile, from humour, recognition and understanding. Hopefully she really is that champion and it's not just all that sugar in her tea!
As I'm sure the publisher's hoped, 'How to be Champion' would make a lovely stocking filler, something that can be enjoyed in short bursts during the morning commute or the five minutes you get to yourself after the kids have gone to bed. While it's definitely one for the girls and a bit on the disposable side, it did it's job well and it certainly has a place on my bookshelves. Like Millican herself, it's brave, brassy and yet compassionate, akin to a supportive hug and a 'It'll be alright, pet.'. We all need one of those from time to time.
Now, what next...
Comedian Sarah Millican's 'How to Be Champion' is part memoir, part self-help and part amusing musings on life. Covering subjects as diverse as school, proper jobs, bullying, relationships, getting into stand up and the weirdness of fame, she shares stories, tips and even a recipe, all the while reminding us that life can be both sad and funny and sometimes both. Above all, this book is about how to deal with it in a way that makes you feel 'champion', even when things don't go how you anticipate and society's expectations just want to get in your way.
OK, I'll start with the negative. Like many celebrity books, the structure for this one goes a bit wobbly a bit towards the end. It's almost like there was a set word count and once the timeline from school to the present had been more or less exhausted, there was a sort of 'what do I say now?' moment. Fortunately, it doesn't last too long and Millican regains momentum to get us to the end of the book.
On the whole, this was exactly what I expected and wanted it to be. Millican's joie de vivre shines from every page, meaning that this was a book I was happy to return to and could trust to raise a smile, from humour, recognition and understanding. Hopefully she really is that champion and it's not just all that sugar in her tea!
As I'm sure the publisher's hoped, 'How to be Champion' would make a lovely stocking filler, something that can be enjoyed in short bursts during the morning commute or the five minutes you get to yourself after the kids have gone to bed. While it's definitely one for the girls and a bit on the disposable side, it did it's job well and it certainly has a place on my bookshelves. Like Millican herself, it's brave, brassy and yet compassionate, akin to a supportive hug and a 'It'll be alright, pet.'. We all need one of those from time to time.
Now, what next...
28 July 2017
Princess Direst?
There are many battle lines drawn to divide the sexes, but the one that's worried me most in recent years is that in the toy shop. I know I'm fairly old and quite absent minded, but was there really always such an obvious difference between toys aimed at girls and toys aimed at boys? Just as I thought I might be seeing my own childhood through rose tinted specs, along came 'Cinderella Ate My Daughter' by American journalist, author and parent Peggy Orenstein, a book which asks the very same question.
'Cinderella Ate My Daughter' is Ms Orenstein's exploration of 'princess' culture, its origins and
whether it's really as bad as it seems. As a mother, she's worried by the impact of girly girl culture on her daughter's character and ambitions. As a vocal feminist and writer, she finds her own world view and reputation are being challenged. Orenstein dives in at the deep end, going to junior beauty pageants, a Miley Cyrus concert and upmarket doll shops (complete with beauty parlour), as well as hanging out with social media obsessed preteens. But can she get beyond the glitter and froth to the facts that matter?
I really enjoyed this book. Admittedly, it was on a topic that interested me, but it was also written in an accessible style by someone who clearly found the apparently sudden emergence of extreme princess culture as baffling as I do. Through the book, Orenstein muses on the topic in an open minded way, trying to draw conclusions that are both rooted in real evidence (rather than hard line reactionism) and pragmatic, recognising peer pressure and that a simple 'No' is not always the best answer.
There are probably a good proportion of parents who have had similar worries to Orenstein about whether princess culture is narrowing their daughters' futures, even condemning them to a life chasing unrealistic expectations about their looks and relationships. This book is written from that perspective and, as such, I would recommend it to them as a good read. It's debatable whether any firm conclusions are drawn, but at least it offers food for thought and makes you realise you're not the only one questioning the giant, pink marketing tsunami that's determined to sweep all girls into a narrow target group.
What I would really like to see next from Ms. Orenstein is a companion work about the boys. For every pink and glittery aisle there's a blue and mechanical one which is arguably just as restrictive. Why should shoving girls in a box be any worse than shoving boys in one?
If you're someone with female children or an interest in this topic, I recommend this book. While it doesn't necessarily give you answers, it does give you information, and in the least will leave you feeling empowered enough to tell the princess to push off once in a while.
Now, what next...
'Cinderella Ate My Daughter' is Ms Orenstein's exploration of 'princess' culture, its origins and
| 'Cinderella Ate My Daughter' by Peggy Orenstein (Harper, 2012) |
I really enjoyed this book. Admittedly, it was on a topic that interested me, but it was also written in an accessible style by someone who clearly found the apparently sudden emergence of extreme princess culture as baffling as I do. Through the book, Orenstein muses on the topic in an open minded way, trying to draw conclusions that are both rooted in real evidence (rather than hard line reactionism) and pragmatic, recognising peer pressure and that a simple 'No' is not always the best answer.
There are probably a good proportion of parents who have had similar worries to Orenstein about whether princess culture is narrowing their daughters' futures, even condemning them to a life chasing unrealistic expectations about their looks and relationships. This book is written from that perspective and, as such, I would recommend it to them as a good read. It's debatable whether any firm conclusions are drawn, but at least it offers food for thought and makes you realise you're not the only one questioning the giant, pink marketing tsunami that's determined to sweep all girls into a narrow target group.
What I would really like to see next from Ms. Orenstein is a companion work about the boys. For every pink and glittery aisle there's a blue and mechanical one which is arguably just as restrictive. Why should shoving girls in a box be any worse than shoving boys in one?
If you're someone with female children or an interest in this topic, I recommend this book. While it doesn't necessarily give you answers, it does give you information, and in the least will leave you feeling empowered enough to tell the princess to push off once in a while.
Now, what next...
09 April 2016
Vote Moran!
I had a lovely surprise recently - I won a competition I'd forgotten I'd entered! This is how, thanks to Ebury Publishing, I ended up with a signed copy of Caitlin Moran's latest book, 'Moranifesto'. And because it was something I really wanted to read, I'm afraid I went off list again...
In 'Moranifesto', Ms Moran eases to the fore the more political aspects of her writing. This is a woman who manages to cover both 'parties' (Noun: Social gatherings or celebrations, often involving food, music and copious amounts of gin) and 'parties' (Noun: Collections of people with shared political ideologies and aims, usually to get elected and/or bring down the PM/tease Jeremy Corbyn). As a result, this book covers everything from hipsters, the uncooperative nature of printers, fame, TV, the Olympics and the Queen's Diamond Jubilee to feminism, tax, social mobility, FGM, the ruling elite, equality, wind turbines and more. It is indeed as wide, varied and potentially powerful as a manifesto, full of energy and ideas. If only manifestos were this grounded and readable.
There are three things I want to get out of the way first:
The news can often make it seem like we're small and insignificant, swept up on a tsunami of decision making designed to fuel a better future for other people, while drowning out all opportunity and hope for us and the people we love. It's books like this one that make you realise that you're not alone or imagining it, that other people, with voices in the media, are also going "WTF?"
So, while I would've liked this book to be a bit braver and unembarrassed by being political, I do feel it's another step in a march towards a greater debate. It's books like 'Moranifesto' which will inspire and motivate the politically alienated and apathetic in a way carefully rehearsed, PR-approved speeches and dense, complicated manifestos never will. Whether you agree with it or not, it will get you thinking and, hopefully, talking.
What would I like Moran to do next? I'm tempted to say "Deeds not words", but that's easier said than done, isn't it? It's one thing to stick your head above the parapet and say things aren't right, but quite another to come up with practical ways to change things. But getting people talking is a start. And giving me a copy of the book definitely got me talking. On top of that, I'll share and debate this book with other people too. I've heard that's how revolutions happen.
Speaking of which, I wonder how Ross Poldark is getting on in revolutionary France? Time to get back to 'The Black Moon'...
Related Posts
'Moranthology' by Caitlin Moran - Starts with one of the funniest things I've ever read.
'How to be a Woman' by Caitlin Moran - Common sense feminism for the everyday.
| 'Moranifesto' by Caitlin Moran (Ebury Press, 2016) |
There are three things I want to get out of the way first:
- This book is too expensive. I thoroughly enjoyed Ms Moran's previous collections and was thrilled when I found that another was out, but going into the bookshop and seeing a price tag of £20 made me baulk. If I hadn't been given a copy, this review wouldn't have appeared until after the paperback was published or I'd got a copy from the library.
- This book is too long. While I enjoyed so much of this book and respect that there was a delicate balance going on, where the editors were trying to ease fans of the funny, everyday, social observation pieces into the tougher, witty, political and polemical parts, I do feel some sections didn't really work. And. weirdly, although they only happened four years ago, the Diamond Jubilee and London Olympics already feel like ancient history, unlike the contemporary commentary offered by most of the articles.
- The typos were distracting. Publishers: If you can't afford proofreaders, there are plenty of people like me out there who would quite happily read your forthcoming books and point out any errors. And I bet a lot would do it in exchange for free books. It's the barter economy. (Honest. I'm not really just looking for a new way to get free books.)
The news can often make it seem like we're small and insignificant, swept up on a tsunami of decision making designed to fuel a better future for other people, while drowning out all opportunity and hope for us and the people we love. It's books like this one that make you realise that you're not alone or imagining it, that other people, with voices in the media, are also going "WTF?"
So, while I would've liked this book to be a bit braver and unembarrassed by being political, I do feel it's another step in a march towards a greater debate. It's books like 'Moranifesto' which will inspire and motivate the politically alienated and apathetic in a way carefully rehearsed, PR-approved speeches and dense, complicated manifestos never will. Whether you agree with it or not, it will get you thinking and, hopefully, talking.
| Look! It really is a signed copy! |
Speaking of which, I wonder how Ross Poldark is getting on in revolutionary France? Time to get back to 'The Black Moon'...
Related Posts
'Moranthology' by Caitlin Moran - Starts with one of the funniest things I've ever read.
'How to be a Woman' by Caitlin Moran - Common sense feminism for the everyday.
Labels:
caitlin moran,
comment,
contemporary,
feminism,
funny,
humour,
manifesto,
moranifesto,
politics,
uk
17 January 2016
The Princess Tried
As you may have gathered by now, it's really unusual for me to finish a book in less than a day. One work that has managed to fall into this elite category, though, is 'Little Tales of Misogyny' by Patricia Highsmith, author of 'Carol' (AKA 'The Price of Salt') and 'The Talented Mr Ripley'.
Published in the early 1970s, 'Little Tales of Misogyny' is a collection of (very) short stories, each exploring a particular female stereotype prevalent at the time. We meet manipulative coquettes, perpetual mothers, unfaithful wives, disposable sex objects and innocent-looking psychopaths. They can be passive, compliant or silent, principled, vocal or bossy. With calm cruelty and dark humour, Highsmith takes the tracks onto which females can be tied, then follows them to apparently inevitable endings.
This book is a very interesting exploration of the female identities that women might choose, or feel expected, to fulfil. It's the sort of book that would have fascinated me as a teenager, negotiating what sort of woman I wanted to be in a world of conflicting instincts, expectations and media messages.
'Little Tales of Misogyny' is essentially a collection of adult fairy tales, controversial because of the way they reduce their subjects to black-and-white stereotypes fixated on an acceptable female role and invoke murder and rape in cold, matter-of-fact ways, as though they are the inevitable results of being a certain type of girl/woman. There are times when I was wondering whether the author actually hated women and this was her way of ridiculing and punishing them and their follies. In the end, however, I finished the book feeling that it was more a frustrated cry to draw attention to the ridiculous way women can behave and be treated by men, each other and themselves.
As with traditional fairy tales, I'd like to think that they represent something historic and long gone, that many of these stereotypes no longer exist in the 21st century, made irrelevant by increased opportunities and better education for women. But it is often easier to slip into the role that's expected of you rather than push for something else and not every girl is fortunate to grow up in an affluent country which recognises the importance of equality and fulfillment for all its citizens.
Overall, I think 'Little Tales of Misogyny' is an interesting read for anyone interested in feminism and women's roles and aspirations. While it isn't the usual taut suspense thriller that Highsmith is famous for, it does feature her sharp character portraits and dark edge. An interesting and thought provoking read indeed.
08 November 2015
Riding Along on the Crest of Fourth Wave
Feminism is cool. After what seems like decades of confinement to university campuses, niche publications and the WI, it's bursting through to mainstream culture in a tidal wave. Feminism is surfacing on TV, in cinemas, in popular books, in mainstream magazines... it's even on t-shirts! It feels like its being talked about and owned by young women in a way not seen for 30 years and people from all walks of life are taking an interest.
One of those people is stand up comedian Bridget Christie. Prince Charming and I have read Ms. Christie's book, 'A Book for Her (and Him if He can Read)', so in this post you're getting two for the price of one. You lucky people!
'A Book for Her' is part career-memoir and part personal journey. In it, Ms Christie talks about how an unfortunate bookseller farting in a shop's Women's Studies section set her off on a journey which leads to her becoming the go-to 'feminist comedian'. The whole journey seems to have surprised her as much as anything else. She begins with a feeling that she needs to know more, but the event puts a wind in her sails that leads her to use her comedic writing and performing talents to bring some of the very harrowing key issues in modern feminism to the fore.
Prince Charming was a bit worried about reading 'A Book for Her (And Him if He Can Read)'. "'Thank goodness for this book's subtitle. Before I read it, I made sure I went away and dug out my old Peter and Jane books to learn to read. I worked really hard and made sure I could read before tackling Ms Christie's book, although some of the long words still eluded me and I had to ask Eileen what they meant."
Well, that's what dictionaries are for, isn't it? Fortunately, I'd already learned to read, although I was finding it hard to work out which book I was supposed to read, being a woman and all that. That's probably why I ended up with so many, I was looking for one which told me it was the one for me, you know, made it REALLY obvious. If only more of them were pink with pictures of women on, it would make the whole process an awful lot easier and I wouldn't get so swept up in Waterstones.
Once he'd got to grips with all the words and reading malarkey, I found I had to put up with Prince Charming laughing quite a lot at this book. As he puts it "Overall, I enjoyed the book. It was funny and thought provoking." Goodness, he's right! It is both funny and thought provoking, getting steadily more powerful as Christie finds her feet and begins talking about the issues she feels strongest about, in particular Female Genital Mutilation (FGM). As she learned more, so did I, which made this a worthwhile, if disjointed, read.
I've read a number of books about feminist issues. They've varied from factual essay-style texts or to passionate and well-informed, well, rants. 'A Book for Her' is different because it's about a relatively ordinary woman working out what feminism means to her and deciding for herself why it's important. She says that she's not well informed about it at the start, but she has curiosity and a thirst for knowledge, which lead her to a cause and a desire to use the skills she has to change the world.
The book does feel dubiously structured, however, much like a sandcastle as the tide comes in. It's almost as if Christie just started writing, without any sort of plan, and it's not until about half way through, as she starts talking about her career to date and transformation into a 'feminist comedian', that she seems to find her feet. From then on, it's very readable and interesting. Before that, it's funny, but rather meandering and doesn't really push you to keep reading.
Prince Charming agreed. "I would though have preferred two books, one about Ms Christie's stand up shows as they all sounded interesting and one about the serious issues the book covers. The two themes could have done with a book each as I felt the direction of the book got lost trying to do both." That's a man speaking. And I agree with him, so it must be right!
For me, this book had the strange effect of making me want to watch Christie's previous shows on DVD. But, oddly, they're not available, as far as I can tell anyway. I blame the patriarchy.
Overall, I felt that this was a good book for the cautious in that it's about a personal relationship with feminism, a thoughtful consideration of why the subject is important rather than an impassioned scream telling us it has to be. I will always be grateful to it for the information it provides on FGM. I'd heard the term before, but was shocked by what I read here. And I bet this is just the tip of the iceberg.
Now that's feminism covered, we're off to read about monster trucks...
![]() |
| 'A Book for Her (And Him if He Can Read)' by Bridget Christie (Century, 2015) |
'A Book for Her' is part career-memoir and part personal journey. In it, Ms Christie talks about how an unfortunate bookseller farting in a shop's Women's Studies section set her off on a journey which leads to her becoming the go-to 'feminist comedian'. The whole journey seems to have surprised her as much as anything else. She begins with a feeling that she needs to know more, but the event puts a wind in her sails that leads her to use her comedic writing and performing talents to bring some of the very harrowing key issues in modern feminism to the fore.
Prince Charming was a bit worried about reading 'A Book for Her (And Him if He Can Read)'. "'Thank goodness for this book's subtitle. Before I read it, I made sure I went away and dug out my old Peter and Jane books to learn to read. I worked really hard and made sure I could read before tackling Ms Christie's book, although some of the long words still eluded me and I had to ask Eileen what they meant."
Well, that's what dictionaries are for, isn't it? Fortunately, I'd already learned to read, although I was finding it hard to work out which book I was supposed to read, being a woman and all that. That's probably why I ended up with so many, I was looking for one which told me it was the one for me, you know, made it REALLY obvious. If only more of them were pink with pictures of women on, it would make the whole process an awful lot easier and I wouldn't get so swept up in Waterstones.
Once he'd got to grips with all the words and reading malarkey, I found I had to put up with Prince Charming laughing quite a lot at this book. As he puts it "Overall, I enjoyed the book. It was funny and thought provoking." Goodness, he's right! It is both funny and thought provoking, getting steadily more powerful as Christie finds her feet and begins talking about the issues she feels strongest about, in particular Female Genital Mutilation (FGM). As she learned more, so did I, which made this a worthwhile, if disjointed, read.
I've read a number of books about feminist issues. They've varied from factual essay-style texts or to passionate and well-informed, well, rants. 'A Book for Her' is different because it's about a relatively ordinary woman working out what feminism means to her and deciding for herself why it's important. She says that she's not well informed about it at the start, but she has curiosity and a thirst for knowledge, which lead her to a cause and a desire to use the skills she has to change the world.
The book does feel dubiously structured, however, much like a sandcastle as the tide comes in. It's almost as if Christie just started writing, without any sort of plan, and it's not until about half way through, as she starts talking about her career to date and transformation into a 'feminist comedian', that she seems to find her feet. From then on, it's very readable and interesting. Before that, it's funny, but rather meandering and doesn't really push you to keep reading.
Prince Charming agreed. "I would though have preferred two books, one about Ms Christie's stand up shows as they all sounded interesting and one about the serious issues the book covers. The two themes could have done with a book each as I felt the direction of the book got lost trying to do both." That's a man speaking. And I agree with him, so it must be right!
For me, this book had the strange effect of making me want to watch Christie's previous shows on DVD. But, oddly, they're not available, as far as I can tell anyway. I blame the patriarchy.
Overall, I felt that this was a good book for the cautious in that it's about a personal relationship with feminism, a thoughtful consideration of why the subject is important rather than an impassioned scream telling us it has to be. I will always be grateful to it for the information it provides on FGM. I'd heard the term before, but was shocked by what I read here. And I bet this is just the tip of the iceberg.
Now that's feminism covered, we're off to read about monster trucks...
17 March 2015
Dolly Folly
I felt I needed a bit of a challenge when I last went to my shelves, so decided on something I hoped would be interesting and thought provoking. That something was 'Living Dolls: The Return of Sexism' by Natasha Walter.
First published five years ago, 'Living Dolls' explores two key issues in modern feminism; The hypersexualisation of western culture and the resurgence of biological determinism as the answer to everything. Modern western women have more freedoms than ever before, so why is our culture increasingly dominated by a vision of femininity that forces females into an unrealistic, doll-shaped coffin? Is the rise of raunch, lads mags and the acceptance of pole dancing, pornography and prostitution into mainstream culture really about choice and empowerment? Should we really just lie back and let it happen because it's in our DNA?
I love a book that makes me think and this certainly did. It was a lot less intimidating than some books on feminism because it was relatively short at 238 pages, but there were enough fireworks in every chapter to make it more than explosive.
I have to admit that I found the first half, The New Sexism, much easier to read than the second, The New Determinism. It had a more journalistic style, featuring stories and quotes from various people that were very interesting and gave a range of perspectives. The second part dealt with more scientific data and experiments, so took more concentration, but I'm grateful to Ms Walter for lifting the lid on a shocking and dangerous perversion of the spirit of enquiry that science represents. I will never read about scientific research in the popular media in the same way again.
In particular, I found the observations on motherhood and the pattern of behaviour and prejudice created by current maternity/paternity rules fascinating. I hope a few of our politicians read this book and see the far reaching consequences of legislation based on a traditional picture of family life that is artificially perpetuated rather than natural. How many glass obstacles could be smashed with a simple change to these rules.
Although I felt that the length of this book was about right for me, I would've liked to explore two things further. The experiences of men are touched on, but I would've liked to have known more about whether they feel as uncomfortable with the hypersexualisation of our culture. After all, it ignores their intelligence and treats them like they're only interested in sex. Isn't that insulting to them too? It also seems to me that men are also beginning to come under pressure to have the perfect, Ken doll body - I mean, seriously, even Poldark has a six pack in 2015! I think I would've been interested to know more about this too. (And by 'this' I mean the pressure on men to look a certain way, not Poldark's six pack. Prince Charming reads this blog for crying out loud!)
Admittedly, women have a bigger job on their hands, trying to tackle thousands of years of ingrained oppression and stereotyping, but it's interesting to look at all the consequences of sexism, not just for women. Once it's shown to be bad for everyone, it should become impossible to deny the need for change.
| 'Living Dolls: The Return of Sexism' by Natasha Walter (Virago, 2010/11) |
I love a book that makes me think and this certainly did. It was a lot less intimidating than some books on feminism because it was relatively short at 238 pages, but there were enough fireworks in every chapter to make it more than explosive.
I have to admit that I found the first half, The New Sexism, much easier to read than the second, The New Determinism. It had a more journalistic style, featuring stories and quotes from various people that were very interesting and gave a range of perspectives. The second part dealt with more scientific data and experiments, so took more concentration, but I'm grateful to Ms Walter for lifting the lid on a shocking and dangerous perversion of the spirit of enquiry that science represents. I will never read about scientific research in the popular media in the same way again.
In particular, I found the observations on motherhood and the pattern of behaviour and prejudice created by current maternity/paternity rules fascinating. I hope a few of our politicians read this book and see the far reaching consequences of legislation based on a traditional picture of family life that is artificially perpetuated rather than natural. How many glass obstacles could be smashed with a simple change to these rules.
Although I felt that the length of this book was about right for me, I would've liked to explore two things further. The experiences of men are touched on, but I would've liked to have known more about whether they feel as uncomfortable with the hypersexualisation of our culture. After all, it ignores their intelligence and treats them like they're only interested in sex. Isn't that insulting to them too? It also seems to me that men are also beginning to come under pressure to have the perfect, Ken doll body - I mean, seriously, even Poldark has a six pack in 2015! I think I would've been interested to know more about this too. (And by 'this' I mean the pressure on men to look a certain way, not Poldark's six pack. Prince Charming reads this blog for crying out loud!)
Admittedly, women have a bigger job on their hands, trying to tackle thousands of years of ingrained oppression and stereotyping, but it's interesting to look at all the consequences of sexism, not just for women. Once it's shown to be bad for everyone, it should become impossible to deny the need for change.
28 September 2014
Treasure Trove
Considering I'm trying to read so many books, I think I've been pretty lucky so far. I've only found a handful so unbearable that I've not finished them and have unearthed so many hidden gems that the project has often been a delight.
One such brilliant discovery is the latest book sent to me by Waterstones, 'Love and Treasure' by American author Ayelet Waldman.
'Love and Treasure' is the story of a stunning peacock-shaped pendant, three remarkable women and
the men who loved them. Interwoven with key political and social shifts in the last 100 years, this excellent book is set in three eras. In 1945, the jewel is found by American soldier Captain Jack Wiseman among the vast contents of the Hungarian Gold Train, stolen from the Jews during World War II and now under his care. As he falls in love with the determined concentration camp survivor Ilona, Jack finds himself torn between his personal sense of justice, the demands of his distant superiors and how unlikely the property can be returned to its rightful owners. More than 60 years later, Wiseman's granddaughter, Natalie, has joined forces with Amitai Shasho, a specialist dealer in items seized by the Nazis, to return the unique jewel. Amitai has recognised the piece from a lost painting he has spent a lifetime tracing. Together, they hope to find both the owner's descendants and the elusive artwork. Finally, in 1913, a strong-minded young woman in Budapest is sent to a pioneering psychoanalyst after defying her family and pursuing her dream of a medical career. A campaigner for women's suffrage, her passion and politics lead her into danger. But how is she connected with the peacock pendant?
I found 'Love and Treasure' a fascinating page turner and incredibly hard to put down. I was very sad to finish it. I knew nothing about the Hungarian Gold Train before I started reading the novel and would now very much like to know more about it and this time period. I always enjoy a book which lets me learn something new.
I felt that the part set in post-war Salzburg was the strongest, but moving between different times helped remind the reader that the dramatic events of one era often have their origins many years before and will cause ripples long into the future. That is why history is important; it helps us understand why things are as they are and where they could lead.
The author has successfully written people not just characters, each with complex motivations and beliefs that felt authentic to their time period, no matter how ridiculous they look through 21st century eyes. No-one could be classed wholly as a hero or villain, but all are conflicted and often naive and confused, trying to make good moral choices and judgements is a less than honourable world. They were often torn between the just and the practical and it was easy to find yourself wondering what you'd do in the same situation.
My only criticism of 'Love and Treasure' is that I felt it needed some minor adaptation for the UK market, perhaps in the form of an added glossary. Aspects of Jewish culture are not so well known here and I regularly had to reach for the dictionary to look things up, which obviously interrupted the narrative's flow. Basically, a certain level of prior knowledge was presumed and, while US readers must be better informed on the subject, I think ordinary UK readers may struggle.
Overall, I thoroughly recommend this book and I hope to read more by this author in the future. It is indeed a novel to love and treasure.
Now for something completely different!
One such brilliant discovery is the latest book sent to me by Waterstones, 'Love and Treasure' by American author Ayelet Waldman.
'Love and Treasure' is the story of a stunning peacock-shaped pendant, three remarkable women and
![]() |
| 'Love and Treasure' by Ayelet Waldman (Two Roads, 2014) |
I found 'Love and Treasure' a fascinating page turner and incredibly hard to put down. I was very sad to finish it. I knew nothing about the Hungarian Gold Train before I started reading the novel and would now very much like to know more about it and this time period. I always enjoy a book which lets me learn something new.
I felt that the part set in post-war Salzburg was the strongest, but moving between different times helped remind the reader that the dramatic events of one era often have their origins many years before and will cause ripples long into the future. That is why history is important; it helps us understand why things are as they are and where they could lead.
The author has successfully written people not just characters, each with complex motivations and beliefs that felt authentic to their time period, no matter how ridiculous they look through 21st century eyes. No-one could be classed wholly as a hero or villain, but all are conflicted and often naive and confused, trying to make good moral choices and judgements is a less than honourable world. They were often torn between the just and the practical and it was easy to find yourself wondering what you'd do in the same situation.
My only criticism of 'Love and Treasure' is that I felt it needed some minor adaptation for the UK market, perhaps in the form of an added glossary. Aspects of Jewish culture are not so well known here and I regularly had to reach for the dictionary to look things up, which obviously interrupted the narrative's flow. Basically, a certain level of prior knowledge was presumed and, while US readers must be better informed on the subject, I think ordinary UK readers may struggle.
Overall, I thoroughly recommend this book and I hope to read more by this author in the future. It is indeed a novel to love and treasure.
Now for something completely different!
01 September 2014
Polite, Silly, Pointing
Two weeks and one cold ago, I finished reading 'Moranthology' by Caitlin Moran and it's taken me until now to get posting about it. It turns out sometimes you just have to take paracetamol, go to bed and stay warm to get over mild winter diseases rather than just keep going. Who knew?!
'Moranthology' is a collection of columns and interviews written by everywoman, journalist, author and reviewer Caitlin Moran. They are as wild, hilarious and eclectic as I imagine the Times columnist to be, saying "boo!" to the Zeitgeist before scampering off with an informative snapshot taken at an interesting angle. Moran's subjects are wide ranging and varied, including everything from couple's pet names to hair copyright, 'Sherlock' to Aberystwyth, 'Ghostbusters' to Lady Gaga. But she also uses her unique life experience to offer readers a new perspective on socio-political issues too, such as drugs, poverty, tax evasion, library closures, benefit cuts and mental illness. We laugh, but we also learn.
Overall, this is a great 'dip into' sort of book, perfect for a short daily commute (on public transport, obviously) or anyone who 'doesn't have time to read'. I stopped buying newspapers regularly when a) they started costing £1 a day and b) I realised I didn't really have time to read them anyway, so being able to get a book like this collecting some brilliant opinion pieces offered me a middle way. Publish one once a year and I'm sorted.
My one criticism, I suppose, would be that this book starts on such a high that it was only ever going to go down. The opening piece is a (possibly imagined) conversation between Moran and her husband about their pet names for each other. I won't say any more, but Prince Charming also read this piece and laughed as much as I did. It's almost unfair on the other columns!
'Moranthology' is a cool, funny, interesting, thought-provoking, sassy, proud book and when I reached the end I felt like I'd just finished the most interesting conversation I'd ever had. So here's everything crossed for a 'Moranthology II'.
Related Posts
Feminism Goes Funny - 'How to be a Woman' by Caitlin Moran
![]() |
| 'Moranthology' by Caitlin Moran (Ebury, 2012) |
Overall, this is a great 'dip into' sort of book, perfect for a short daily commute (on public transport, obviously) or anyone who 'doesn't have time to read'. I stopped buying newspapers regularly when a) they started costing £1 a day and b) I realised I didn't really have time to read them anyway, so being able to get a book like this collecting some brilliant opinion pieces offered me a middle way. Publish one once a year and I'm sorted.
My one criticism, I suppose, would be that this book starts on such a high that it was only ever going to go down. The opening piece is a (possibly imagined) conversation between Moran and her husband about their pet names for each other. I won't say any more, but Prince Charming also read this piece and laughed as much as I did. It's almost unfair on the other columns!
'Moranthology' is a cool, funny, interesting, thought-provoking, sassy, proud book and when I reached the end I felt like I'd just finished the most interesting conversation I'd ever had. So here's everything crossed for a 'Moranthology II'.
Related Posts
Feminism Goes Funny - 'How to be a Woman' by Caitlin Moran
01 August 2014
Shooting from the Hip
A few weeks ago, the lovely people at Blinding Books were kind enough to send me a copy of 'My Baby Shot Me Down', an anthology of poetry and prose by ten women writers. Now, I know I shouldn't really stray from my list, but they asked so nicely. And I love a good short story.
'My Baby Shot Me Down' features the work of Clarissa Angus, Katherine Black, Maggy van Eijk, Harriet Goodale, Deborah Hambrook, Claudine Lazar, Rachael Smart, Ruth Starling, Alison Wassell and Laura Wilkinson. Some are award winners, but all could be described as up-and-coming writers. The selected pieces range from the tragic to the poignant to the funny and capture the lives of women and girls of all ages.
OK, confession time. I didn't read all of this book. Now you've picked yourselves up off of the floor, here's why. I've never really understood poetry and, despite the best efforts of my school teachers, find it a completely alien language that is impenetrable to me. It's not the poet's fault at all and no reflection on the quality of the work in 'My Baby Shot Me Down', but after a couple of attempts I did skip all the poetry in this volume to focus on the work I could enjoy.
I do absolutely love short stories and this book includes a number of memorable examples. They range from the bitterly funny 'A Game to Play', about how to be an (im)perfect man, and 'The Great Escape', the tale of how institutional help can hinder, to the chilling 'The Whispering Wall' and 'Mr Brown'. 'Ashes' and 'Love and App-iness' made me laugh, while 'We'll Meet Again' and 'Tissue Atlas' made me cry. 'Buried' reminded me of summers long ago. 'Supermarket Secrets' made me realise how rare it is to read about ordinary women in more ordinary jobs rather than journalists, actors, lawyers and PRs.
Overall, this book is great as a showcase for not-quite-discovered writing talent, demonstrating depth and breadth as well as bringing to the fore themes that women in particular can relate to. Although some of the flash fiction felt a bit too short, the book is certainly thought provoking. I suddenly realised after reading 'Supermarket Secrets' that I couldn't think of any other piece of fiction set in a supermarket, which is odd when you consider how many people work in them and how ubiquitous they are. It also got me wondering about the way book genres work. I know I read an awful lot of historical fiction and not nearly enough modern books, but am I imagining the disproportionate number of strong women in the former? Only reading my 500-odd books will tell!
This anthology worked its magic enough for me to want to buy other work by these authors. They are certainly names to watch and I would recommend 'My Baby Shot Me Down' to anyone keen to try something new.
| 'My Baby Shot Me Down' by Various Authors (Blinding Books, 2014) |
OK, confession time. I didn't read all of this book. Now you've picked yourselves up off of the floor, here's why. I've never really understood poetry and, despite the best efforts of my school teachers, find it a completely alien language that is impenetrable to me. It's not the poet's fault at all and no reflection on the quality of the work in 'My Baby Shot Me Down', but after a couple of attempts I did skip all the poetry in this volume to focus on the work I could enjoy.
I do absolutely love short stories and this book includes a number of memorable examples. They range from the bitterly funny 'A Game to Play', about how to be an (im)perfect man, and 'The Great Escape', the tale of how institutional help can hinder, to the chilling 'The Whispering Wall' and 'Mr Brown'. 'Ashes' and 'Love and App-iness' made me laugh, while 'We'll Meet Again' and 'Tissue Atlas' made me cry. 'Buried' reminded me of summers long ago. 'Supermarket Secrets' made me realise how rare it is to read about ordinary women in more ordinary jobs rather than journalists, actors, lawyers and PRs.
Overall, this book is great as a showcase for not-quite-discovered writing talent, demonstrating depth and breadth as well as bringing to the fore themes that women in particular can relate to. Although some of the flash fiction felt a bit too short, the book is certainly thought provoking. I suddenly realised after reading 'Supermarket Secrets' that I couldn't think of any other piece of fiction set in a supermarket, which is odd when you consider how many people work in them and how ubiquitous they are. It also got me wondering about the way book genres work. I know I read an awful lot of historical fiction and not nearly enough modern books, but am I imagining the disproportionate number of strong women in the former? Only reading my 500-odd books will tell!
This anthology worked its magic enough for me to want to buy other work by these authors. They are certainly names to watch and I would recommend 'My Baby Shot Me Down' to anyone keen to try something new.
Labels:
anthology,
award-winning,
contemporary,
feminism,
feminist,
new,
poems,
poetry,
short stories,
women,
writers
16 November 2012
Feminism goes Funny
I've just finished reading 'How to be a Woman' by Caitlin Moran. I bought it after hearing her on BBC Radio Four's 'Chain Reaction' and was so intrigued by what she said that I wanted to know more.
'How to be a Woman' is a funny, rude, mischievousness, cheeky, honest, realistic, thought provoking, passionate romp through what it means to be a modern woman. Part-autobiography, part feminist rant, it begins with a chilling account of Moran being pursued by a gang of boys as a 13 year old, following her through puberty, then into her first relationships, motherhood and her reflections on what feminism means today.
This book is laugh out loud funny thanks to the author's gloriously irreverent style. The prose rollicks along shamelessly peeping into every nook and cranny of what it's like to grow up as a white, western female of the species before delving into the specific life experiences of the writer. Reading it made me remember things I'd long forgotten and made me marvel at how different we all are as teenagers.
Despite its humour, it is a quite serious book because it does something ordinary women don't do; it makes readers face up to the fact that girls do some pretty potty things that boys simply aren't expected to. Moran talks about many things that have been irritating me for years, but I've always felt like I'm the odd one out for suspecting that there's anything amiss. It's such a relief to find I'm not the only one who thinks the way we behave sometimes is utterly bonkers and distracts us from the more important achievements in life that might get more women in the boardroom or in Parliament.
This is not a book for everyone, however. There is an awful lot of swearing used, which some people may dislike, along with references to heavy drinking and drug taking, which may also cause disapproval.
But I really identified with Moran's arguments and wish there were a few more people willing to pipe up and say that, actually, society's expectations of women are a bit out of order. It's not enough to be clever, talented, generous and rich, women also feel they have to be beautiful, thin, fashionable and popular. Despite hope spread by modern day icons such as Lady Gaga, the princess ideal still lives in showy weddings and WAGs.
I have two hopes as a result of reading this book. 1) That Moran will revisit it when her daughters are older and see how her experiences compare with theirs and how things have changed since she was their age. 2) That someone will write 'How to be a Man' so we can hear the other side of the story. There's part of me that suspects that a lot of men think what we do is bonkers too. Worse still, I think a few of them are also getting sucked into bad habits like worrying about body image too.
Right, back to the shelves!
'How to be a Woman' is a funny, rude, mischievousness, cheeky, honest, realistic, thought provoking, passionate romp through what it means to be a modern woman. Part-autobiography, part feminist rant, it begins with a chilling account of Moran being pursued by a gang of boys as a 13 year old, following her through puberty, then into her first relationships, motherhood and her reflections on what feminism means today.
This book is laugh out loud funny thanks to the author's gloriously irreverent style. The prose rollicks along shamelessly peeping into every nook and cranny of what it's like to grow up as a white, western female of the species before delving into the specific life experiences of the writer. Reading it made me remember things I'd long forgotten and made me marvel at how different we all are as teenagers.
Despite its humour, it is a quite serious book because it does something ordinary women don't do; it makes readers face up to the fact that girls do some pretty potty things that boys simply aren't expected to. Moran talks about many things that have been irritating me for years, but I've always felt like I'm the odd one out for suspecting that there's anything amiss. It's such a relief to find I'm not the only one who thinks the way we behave sometimes is utterly bonkers and distracts us from the more important achievements in life that might get more women in the boardroom or in Parliament.
This is not a book for everyone, however. There is an awful lot of swearing used, which some people may dislike, along with references to heavy drinking and drug taking, which may also cause disapproval.
But I really identified with Moran's arguments and wish there were a few more people willing to pipe up and say that, actually, society's expectations of women are a bit out of order. It's not enough to be clever, talented, generous and rich, women also feel they have to be beautiful, thin, fashionable and popular. Despite hope spread by modern day icons such as Lady Gaga, the princess ideal still lives in showy weddings and WAGs.
I have two hopes as a result of reading this book. 1) That Moran will revisit it when her daughters are older and see how her experiences compare with theirs and how things have changed since she was their age. 2) That someone will write 'How to be a Man' so we can hear the other side of the story. There's part of me that suspects that a lot of men think what we do is bonkers too. Worse still, I think a few of them are also getting sucked into bad habits like worrying about body image too.
Right, back to the shelves!
Labels:
autobiography,
feminism,
feminist,
funny,
humour,
journalism,
melody maker,
the times
04 April 2012
Our Friends in the Deep South
Yesterday, I finished 'The Help' by Kathryn Stockett and I absolutely loved it. It's not a book I would've picked up myself, but someone bought it for me as a birthday present, so I wanted to give it a go. I'm so grateful to them, I had no idea what I was missing out on!
Set in Jackson, Mississippi, in the early 1960s, 'The Help' is the story of the town's African American maids and the white women and families they serve. It has three narrators, Aibileen, a calm, dignified woman who understands the white children she cares for much better than their mothers, the adorably feisty Minny, whose tendency to speak her mind can get her into trouble with her employers, and Skeeter Phelan, a wannabe writer who has just returned from university to find her own beloved maid, Constantine, gone and a wall of silence around exactly what happened. Through their eyes, we see the good, bad and ugly of Jackson society and none are more ugly than the genuinely evil Hilly Holbrook. When the search for Constantine leads Skeeter to start writing a book about the maids and their experiences, the malignant shadow of Hilly and those in her thrall looms large. Skeeter, Aibileen and Minny know the project is important, but can they see it through safely?
I was completely absorbed by the world Ms Stockett has created from the very first page. She's done such an absolutely amazing job of capturing the different characters in this book, I honestly felt like I'd get to the last page and discover they were all real people. I was genuinely disappointed when the book ended as I knew I wouldn't 'see' them again and know that they were OK. Weirdly, they almost felt like friends - that doesn't happen very often!
The whole book is an emotional rollercoaster - I cried, I hoped, I winced, I pitied, I laughed out loud, I sympathised and, in the last few chapters, I was on the edge of my seat. Chopin said "People who never laugh are not serious people." Life is full of funny moments and its a mistake for any author to think their work will be more realistic without them. I love this book all the more for not shieing away from that, even though the underlying themes of racism and prejudice are so serious. Without them, the book would have lost its characteristic energy and sparkle.
Although this is a fantastic book, I think it would appeal mainly to those interested in human relationships, so you might want to think twice if that's not really your thing. Other than that, go! Go out now and buy a copy immediately! Or three! I know I will - an awful lot of my friends will be getting this for their birthdays this year!
| 'The Help' by Kathryn Stockett (Film Tie-in, Penguin, 2011) |
I was completely absorbed by the world Ms Stockett has created from the very first page. She's done such an absolutely amazing job of capturing the different characters in this book, I honestly felt like I'd get to the last page and discover they were all real people. I was genuinely disappointed when the book ended as I knew I wouldn't 'see' them again and know that they were OK. Weirdly, they almost felt like friends - that doesn't happen very often!
The whole book is an emotional rollercoaster - I cried, I hoped, I winced, I pitied, I laughed out loud, I sympathised and, in the last few chapters, I was on the edge of my seat. Chopin said "People who never laugh are not serious people." Life is full of funny moments and its a mistake for any author to think their work will be more realistic without them. I love this book all the more for not shieing away from that, even though the underlying themes of racism and prejudice are so serious. Without them, the book would have lost its characteristic energy and sparkle.
Although this is a fantastic book, I think it would appeal mainly to those interested in human relationships, so you might want to think twice if that's not really your thing. Other than that, go! Go out now and buy a copy immediately! Or three! I know I will - an awful lot of my friends will be getting this for their birthdays this year!
Labels:
best,
book,
civil rights,
Deep South,
excellent,
feminism,
racism,
Sixties,
slavery,
The Help
04 October 2011
Come Again?
In the preface to 'The Picture of Dorian Gray', Oscar Wilde suggests that "There is no such thing as a moral or an immoral book. Books are well written, or badly written. That is all." If ever a book made me think of this quote, it was Ariel Levy's 'Female Chauvinist Pigs'.
'Female Chauvinist Pigs: Women and the Rise of Raunch Culture' is polemical work which looks at how women have fallen into the trap of mimicking and idolising either an extreme form of female sexuality (such as the pole dancer, stripper or porn star) or a hard-nosed, aggressive male stereotype (the sort who would oggle pole dancers etc). Chapters look at the issue from different angles, including the effect on young men and women, it's manifestation in 'boi' culture among New York lesbians and how the author believes the whole issue relates back to consumerism, power and the codification of sexuality.
There was a lot of really interesting information and ideas in this book, but it is really badly written. Even looking beyond the fact that no concession seems to have been made for the British market (Levy is an American writer and the book is clearly aimed at someone with a basic understanding of relevant law and events in that country), there's no clear, logical structure or flow to take the reader on a journey through the writer's ideas. The introduction alone felt rather like an angry, foot-stamping, ranting, tantrum, which was exhausting to read, and, afterall, has anyone ever really had their mind changed by someone shouting at them?
The terrible structure was made all the worse by the fact that there is a lot of really interesting information in this book. I found the chapters looking at US Feminism and how it led to the 'Rise of Raunch Culture' ('The Future that Never Happened') and the effect of this trend on young people ('Pigs in Training') extremely interesting, but still hard work. Although the interviews quoted were a great for grounding the subject, ultimately they weren't enough. More actual statistics would have helped as it was difficult to tell whether the issues discussed were as severe as suggested because so much of the argument felt like it was based on here-say and a very narrow sample of interviews.
This is a book I would love to see rewritten with some more thorough research and better structuring so that it becomes a logical, comprehensible discussion and a cogent argument for reflection and change. The focus on different groups/topics in different chapters is fine, but how information is conveyed within those chapters really needs looking at. Unfortunately, until this happens, I'm afraid that wouldn't recommend it to anyone, which is a real shame as I do believe there is a very important issue being discussed here, possibly even the biggest issue in modern feminism. The trouble is that unless feminists come up with calm, cogent arguments, they can easily be dismissed as hysterical and we'll all be back to square one.
'Female Chauvinist Pigs: Women and the Rise of Raunch Culture' is polemical work which looks at how women have fallen into the trap of mimicking and idolising either an extreme form of female sexuality (such as the pole dancer, stripper or porn star) or a hard-nosed, aggressive male stereotype (the sort who would oggle pole dancers etc). Chapters look at the issue from different angles, including the effect on young men and women, it's manifestation in 'boi' culture among New York lesbians and how the author believes the whole issue relates back to consumerism, power and the codification of sexuality.
| 'Female Chauvinist Pigs' by Ariel Levy (Pocket Books, 2006) |
The terrible structure was made all the worse by the fact that there is a lot of really interesting information in this book. I found the chapters looking at US Feminism and how it led to the 'Rise of Raunch Culture' ('The Future that Never Happened') and the effect of this trend on young people ('Pigs in Training') extremely interesting, but still hard work. Although the interviews quoted were a great for grounding the subject, ultimately they weren't enough. More actual statistics would have helped as it was difficult to tell whether the issues discussed were as severe as suggested because so much of the argument felt like it was based on here-say and a very narrow sample of interviews.
This is a book I would love to see rewritten with some more thorough research and better structuring so that it becomes a logical, comprehensible discussion and a cogent argument for reflection and change. The focus on different groups/topics in different chapters is fine, but how information is conveyed within those chapters really needs looking at. Unfortunately, until this happens, I'm afraid that wouldn't recommend it to anyone, which is a real shame as I do believe there is a very important issue being discussed here, possibly even the biggest issue in modern feminism. The trouble is that unless feminists come up with calm, cogent arguments, they can easily be dismissed as hysterical and we'll all be back to square one.
Labels:
consumerism,
feminism,
playboy,
women's issues
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






