Showing posts with label spirits. Show all posts
Showing posts with label spirits. Show all posts

13 June 2014

Reading Voices (Again)...

Before I start, I want to make one thing clear.  I'm reviewing the book, not the author.  I say this because I've just finished 'A Host of Voices' by Doris Stokes, which includes the third and fourth autobiographies written by the popular psychic medium, and understand her to be a controversial figure to some.

'A Host of Voices' by
Doris Stokes
(Warner Books, 2000)
'A Host of Voices' is two books in one.  'Innocent Voices in My Ear' explores Mrs Stokes particular affinity with parents who have lost children, a connection she feels keenly due to the passing of her only child as a baby. 'Whispering Voices' is broader and covers a range of personal and public events, demonstrations and sittings that took place in around 1984-5.

There are three collections of Doris Stokes' autobiographies and I've now read all of them.  Although I'm not sure I have an opinion on her beliefs, her books have a very easy style and before I've realised it I'm already 50 pages in.  If only more books were like that!  Although where would the challenge be then?

'A Host of Voices' was no exception to this.  It has a charming style that made me feel like I was visiting an elderly relative and she was telling stories about her life and experiences.  'Innocent Voices in my Ear' was a bit of an emotional roller coaster because of the subject matter, so while the style was easy going, sometimes the lives described weren't.  As such, it's not really for the faint hearted.  Or those without hanky to hand.

My favourite chapters were where Stokes talked about her life rather than just relaying the stories of her sitters and celebrity contacts, in this world and the next.  Unfortunately, these were quite few, although I suspect much of this was probably covered in her first to autobiographies.

'Whispering Voices' wasn't as much of a success.  It felt a little as though Mrs Stokes' first three books had been so popular she was encouraged to write a third.  Unfortunately, the source material seems to be running out by this stage and it almost feels as if it's being written as events happen, until there's enough text for a book.  By the end, whole chapters are being devoted to reprinted articles about Mrs Stokes and poetry she's been sent by her admirers.  The former would be more interesting as part of an analysis of Stokes in a socio-cultural context and the latter really only illustrate the author's respect for what her correspondents send her. Which is lovely, but doesn't make for a good read.

Overall, if you are interested in the popular culture of the 1970s and '80s or spiritualism, 'A Host of Voices' and its companions are interesting and, somehow, easy reads, despite being full of loss, crime and suicide.  I think a certain amount of detachment helps the casual reader, although maybe I've just been hardened by reading so many sad stories.  Anyway, I suspect you already know if this is your sort of read or not!

Now the days are longer, I'm hoping to get my teeth (or should that be my head?) into a few more titles.  Although I'm not doing myself any favours at the moment - am part way through two paperpacks, one hard back, an ebook and an audiobook.  But at least I'm reading (or listening!), so watch this space or follow me on Twitter for updates!

Related Posts

Getting into the Spirit of Things...

01 August 2013

The Truth is Out There

After 'The White Queen', I needed a bit of a break from the Plantagenets, so did a bit of a lucky dip and picked up 'Will Storr vs The Supernatural' by Will Storr (funny that!).

In 'Will Storr vs The Supernatural', the journalist tackles some big questions; Do ghosts exist?  Can people be possessed?  Is there life after death?  In 21 snappy chapters, Storr interviews demonologists, paranormal investigators, exorcists, psychologists and psychics looking for answers in some of the shadowiest corners of eccentricity.  Will he find some truth or just get lost in the dark?

Like a scary story, this book just made you keep reading.  Each chapter is punchy and takes you somewhere that most people will never go.  After all, even the most hardened sceptic probably doesn't fancy spending the night in the cold, dark and damp of a supposedly haunted house.

'Will Storr vs The Supernatural'
by Will Storr
(Ebury Press, 2006)
Throughout, our guide manages to tread a careful path between open minded and sceptical, letting his curiosity take control.  The subjects' stories are told with compassion and humanity, never losing sight of the likely driving forces behind their often frowned upon beliefs: loss, insecurity and the fear of death.

Despite its subject, this book is anything but heavy and serious.  It's not a scientific or psychological treatise on the supernatural, so don't expect a convincing argument one way or another.  It's one person's conclusions drawn from his own experiences and encounters.  It's also written for entertainment and while it's not necessarily laugh-out-loud funny, it is amusing without mocking the interviewees or their beliefs.

Overall, I found this book fascinating and loved Storr's style of writing and turn of phrase.  Far from frightening me off, I will be looking up other books by the author and hoping for more of the same.

Now, a bit of time travel.  Back to the Red Queen!

03 August 2011

Getting into the Spirit of things...

My latest book may not be the sort of thing that many people would read, but I hope you'll find my thoughts on it interesting.  I've just finished 'Joyful Voices' by Doris Stokes, an omnibus of her last two autobiographies 'Voices of Love' and 'Joyful Voices'.

In case you're not aware of her, Doris Stokes was a famous medium in the 1970s and '80s.  More specifically, she was called 'clairaudient' because she heard the voices of dead people rather than seeing manifestations of them.  In this book, she talks about her day-to-day life and encounters with grieving families, celebrities and, of course, those in the Spirit World.

'Joyful Voices' by
Doris Stokes
(Sphere 2007)
It can be easy to dismiss people's beliefs as ridiculous, but it's harder to dismiss the person.  That's certainly true of Mrs Stokes.  Whether you agree with her belief in the afterlife or not, it's hard to think her a bad person when she seems to just want to help people to come to terms with their loss.  She comes across as quite a kind hearted person and the book is carried along by her constant optimism and hope for better to come.

I rather liked the style of the book.  It's episodic and chatty and very easy to read, much like a magazine, so it wasn't at all hard going.  It was certainly what I needed after my encounter with Ernest Hemingway!

While it may not be high literature, the book is still an interesting curiosity.  It's fascinating to hear her normalise hearing voices and of particular interest was the transcript of her last sitting at the end of the book. It even led to me looking up some clips of Mrs Stokes on You Tube.  It's genuinely fascinating to see how her at work and I would recommend the clips to anyone interested in finding out more about her activities.

If you want to know more about Mrs Stokes, however, I would suggest that you don't start here.  I've read Mrs Stokes' first omnibus, 'Voices', which included 'Voices in My Ear' and 'More Voices in My Ear'.  I enjoyed the book very much, so, when I saw this one, I snapped it up too.  Unfortunately, it's not as good.  It's not really the author's fault, she was ailing and in her late sixties by the time she wrote her last two books and as a result she just doesn't get about as much as she used to.  As such, the stories become a bit repetitive and, in a strange way, mundane after a while.  The celebrity name dropping becomes irritating too, particularly as I didn't recognise some of the names at all.  There are even whole chapters dedicated to poems sent to her, which is both kinda sweet and irritating at the same time.  Equally, although she's right to not to preach through her books, it's a shame that she avoids the bad press entirely, as it would be interesting to hear her side of the argument.  It's almost as if she's saying "It's up to you love, but which is the nicer idea to live with?"

They say that if you open your mind too much, your brain will fall out, but you don't learn much by keeping it too closed either.  If you're interested in this sort of thing, start with 'Voices'.  If you're not interested in this sort of thing, I'd stay well away.  You're probably not going to enjoy it as the best you can hope to do is insulting a harmless old lady.  And that's a bit low, don't you think?